May a community defending a RLUIPA action seek to identify and depose donors to a religious organization? In Tree of Life Christian School v. City of Upper Arlington, 2012 U.S. Dist, LEXIS 32205 (03.12.12) the Court answered no based on First Amendment free association concerns.
Briefly, in the Tree of Life case, the school purchased land in the City of Upper Arlington, Ohio in an attempt to consolidate its religious facilities into one area. After the purchase was made, the City denied the school the ability to use the property for religious training and a substantial burden RLUIPA case followed. Discovery revealed that the school was provided a donation to purchase the land from one person. The City sought to find out who made the gift and depose the donor in an attempt to inquire if the donor would be willing to donate money to purchase another parcel of land.
In reviewing the federal discovery rules, in light of the Constitutional right of free association, the Court agreed that in some narrow instances, the Constitutional rights of free association trumps the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and discovery. In reviewing the case law following the limitation of disclosure in light of free association rights, the Court held that the City was precluded from inquiring the names of donors and taking the donors deposition. Having determined that naming and deposing the donor would have a “chilling effect” on the school; the Court assessed the City’s interest in obtaining disclosure. Finding the information relevant, but not crucial to the defense of the case, the Court found that the information sought was speculative at best.
This ruling is significant in religious land use cases given that substantial burden cases under RLUIPA, and the First Amendment Free Exercise Clause are fact intensive and discovery in federal actions are broad in scope. Despite the same, the Court recognized that discovery has its limits and following the line of First Amendment cases over the past century, inquiry of donors and the sought after discovery of the same is constitutionally prohibited.
The RLUIPA lawyers at Dalton & Tomich plc will continue to monitor this case through the proceedings.
Dalton & Tomich, PLC is the national leader in successfully helping churches, other religious institutions and their insurers defend their rights in land use and zoning matters under RLUIPA, the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act. We have helped clients win cases against municipalities and other local government bodies from coast to coast, with experience serving both as general counsel and special litigation counsel.
In 2015, Hope Rising Community Church experienced extreme opposition, the kind that would force it to close its doors and leave behind the families and youth it was so passionate about reaching. As the lead pastor I felt helpless, inferior and as if I had no […]Read More
Dalton & Tomich’s assistance in our RLUIPA matter has paved the way for our church to continue serving the community and for new churches in the area to thrive in the future. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts for your stand for religious […]Read More
The Urban Church will be forever grateful to Dalton & Tomich plc for navigating it through a difficult land use issue. Let them give you honest and caring advice because that’s exactly what they’ll do.Read More
Dalton & Tomich, PLC defended a complicated case at a church we insure. Not only is the firm professional, they understand how church business runs and work well within church leadership.Read More
Dalton & Tomich, PLC helped us immensely in the areas of litigation and negotiation! Their professionalism and understanding of church policy helped our church be victorious in a modern day religious land use battle. RLUIPA Religious Land Use Case: Lighthouse Community Church of GodRead More
Dalton & Tomich, PLC serves as General Counsel for the 144 churches within the Church of God in Michigan. The firm provides the legal expertise we need in dealing with the issues that arise during the course of fulfilling our ministry.Read More
I met Dan Dalton during a dark time for our church. He was recommended as the leading RLUIPA attorney in the nation. He demonstrated wisdom, expertise, a gentle nature, a calming inter-relational skill, genuineness, and a humble demeanor, while at the same time, being sharp, […]Read More
Mr. Dalton’s expertise and experience helped us through a very difficult legal journey, ultimately achieving a favorable outcome. His personal interest in helping our church went “above and beyond” just the call of duty. His understanding of both legal and spiritual matters seems to uniquely […]Read More